This is Not a Review: Maher's Filmpocracy

By Sam Husseini

Too much stock is put into actually seeing movies. Once you see a movie, it is harder to criticize it. You've spent your 8 to 13 dollars and your 2 to 3 hours. There's always something to like in a movie, some camera angle (the promo glimpse of "W" collapsing from a pretzel in Oliver Stone's latest offering) some witty line, etc.

Without seeing Maher's movie, I suspect it's ridiculous. Here's why: Maher makes a movie about religion in the modern world. He goes around talking to various religious people, mocking them in some way. A friend, Wendy, subjected herself to it.

I asked her if the film made any mention of Martin Luther King, Jr, arguable the most important figure in the U.S. in the last 100 years and almost certainly the most important religious figure in that period. Nope. No mention of King. Not a word. Hmmm. Now, why would that be? Could it be because mentioning King would undermine Maher's fundamental(ist) thesis about religion being ridiculous? And, like a good fundamentalist, he doesn't want to examine evidence that might unsettle his agenda that religion is something to be mostly mocked.

Here's King on hope:

Our only hope today lies in our ability to recapture the revolutionary spirit and go out into a sometimes hostile world declaring eternal hostility to poverty, racism, and militarism. With this powerful commitment we shall boldly challenge the status quo and unjust mores ... A genuine revolution of values means in the final analysis that our loyalties must become ecumenical rather than sectional. Every nation must now develop an overriding loyalty to mankind as a whole in order to preserve the best in their individual societies. This call for a worldwide fellowship that lifts neighborly concern beyond one's tribe, race, class, and nation is in reality a call for an all-embracing and unconditional love for all mankind.


Pretty tough to mock. Perhaps a certain presidential candidate who talks a lot about hope--and constantly invokes nationalism like it's a good thing--should read King's words.

No mention, Wendy tells me, of Gandhi either who reminded the world that he was not only a Hindu, "I am also a Christian, a Muslim, a Buddhist and a Jew."

Boy, Maher could have a ball mocking Gandhi--he's five-for-one. Albert Einstien famously said that "God does not play dice with the universe." Less famously, he said "Nationalism is an infantile disease. It is the measles of mankind."

The shtick of Maher and other mediocre minds who pretend to be clever is that they want to focus on religion while ignoring the great threat of nationalism. Great minds, like King, Gandhi and Einstein, did the opposite. They attempted to use religion to overcome the possibly catastrophic consequenses of nationalism.

Maher ignores them, as do the crazed right-wingers in each tradition.

My personal problem with religion is not that people believe certain things, it's that I doubt that they actually believe what they way they believe. If they did, they'd act differently. If I really believed that I'd live on after my body dies and have to stand before a God to answer for myself--putting aside for the moment the question of God's accountablity--I'd have very little fear of what humans might do to me. Such a belief would be very liberating.

So many profess it and so few--except for the crazed militarists--seem to show the certainty and true liberation such a world view might facilitate. Maybe the problem is not faith, but hypocracy, of which there seems to be an endless supply.

Comments

(61)

My problem is with these preachers who support McCain

from the pulpit.
How about yanking their tax exempt status IRS? Or are you still too busy auditing working class people?

You mean people like Rev. Wright?

The endorsement of a candidate, or political party is not allowed, the expression of viewpoint is. Maybe the nuance escapes you.

So how's Pat Robertson staying on the air?

Answer me THAT one, Skippy.

If all else fails, immortality can always be assured by spectacular error. ~~~John Kenneth Galbraith

Maybe it has something to do with this being a free country

I seem to have heard someone say something about freedom of speech. Oh wait, I forgot, that concept doesn't translate in your neo-com world, where freedom of approved speech is all thats accepted.

So you're saying

...that Rev. Wright practices hate speech when he calls for the black man to stand up, but Pat Robertson is exercising his freedom of speech when he calls for the assassination of a foreign head of state?

Hypocracy, thy name is hatenomor...I mean naacprep...ooops, liberal holocaust...no, momofuku.

Oh, that's right...I forgot. Wright supports a Democrat. Robertson supports a Republican. IOKIYAR. My bad.

If all else fails, immortality can always be assured by spectacular error. ~~~John Kenneth Galbraith

If The Reverand was telling his congregation who

to vote for, sure. But since he DIDN'T, your pointless point is MOOT, Uncle Tom.

"She's Cheney in drag." Me

Mahoney

Pookie, I seem to remember you spending a lot of time talking about Foley. Are you going to spend the same amount of time talking about Mahoney or does he get a pass because he's a Dem?

"I seem to remember you spending a lot of time talking about Fol

LOL - Nothing else to do, jackoff? You, apparently, have much more time on your hands than I do. However, I'm sure I spent so much time on Foley is because it was you repug moron's that beat the dead horse beyond a bloody pulp by making excuses for him, thus, the need for us to beat you over your empty skull that he didn't deserve any excuses.

Mahoney's an asshole and should resign. Plain and simple. Unless you can't accept that, feel free to argue amongst your many personalities.

"She's Cheney in drag." Me

You are such a hypocrite.

You are such a hypocrite.

Accuse us of being what you yourself are...

Such unusual behavior for a pussy-ass little conservative follower.

You don't have to burn books to destroy a culture. Just get people to stop reading them.
---Ray Bradbury

Please, DO tell, jackoff, how I'm being a hypocrite?

You asked, you received, so ... what are you whining about now, jackoff?

Because unlike you, I call our leaders to the carpet when they do something stupid?

Because, unlike you, I don't make excuses for those who get caught doing the nasty with someone other than their spouse?

Because, unlike you, I make my stance known, ie: resign, and I move on ... there ARE more important issues in this day and age ... unless, of course, you have nothing better to do than try to get me involved in an infernal pissing match over ... nothing ...

Please, regal me with your 'brilliance' as to how I'm being hypocritical ... I'm waiting with bated breath, jackoff ...

"She's Cheney in drag." Me

You are a hypocrite because

You are a hypocrite because you went on and on about how Foley but when it comes to one of your own, it's no big deal. Nobody made any excuses for Foley and he was asked to resigned. Could it be that the only reason you cared about Foley was because it helped your party? Now you say there are more important issues to talk about but when you were talking about Foley, it seemed to be the most important thing out there. I bet if it were a Republican it would be more important to you.

Liar

The Republicans in the House knew about his perverted behavior but did nothing till it became public.

The Dem's knew about it also

The Dem's knew about it also but waited to disclose it until it would benefit them in the election.

I am sure that you can

link to a reliable website to prove your statement, right? No? Do you mean that you are lying, again?

How's this: w w

How's this:

w w w.cnn.com/2006/POLITICS/12/09/foley.emanuel/index.html

What you omitted, Jacking Jumps Boys...

Is that the article you posted, contains no statement or proof of any statement that the release of the Foley information was for political reasons. I suggest you prove it or fuck off.

But then, a republipuss like yourself has no proof of anything, right?

Face it, crybaby. Your Gay Old Pervert party is DEAD.

It's bleeding DEMISED! Bereft of life, it rests in peace! If you hadn't nailed it to FOX NOISE it would be pushing up the daisies! It's a stiff! It has rung down the final curtain and joined the Choir Invisible!

THIS IS AN EX-PARTY!

You don't have to burn books to destroy a culture. Just get people to stop reading them.
---Ray Bradbury

By LiberalIconoclastOctober 14, 2008 - 7:22pm

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2X-bnzzM3xg

If Bernie can conga after death, this damn elephant can too.

LMAO - Now, now, jackoff. You can get your panties

out of the bunch now. Jeez, you are such a GIRL.

See, unlike you, I don't think it's necessary to beat the dead horse beyond a bloody pulp. The only reason, I, as you claim, went on about Foley is because I'm sure you, dumbass, and the other moronic trolls, wouldn't let it go and found it necessary to make excuse after excuse for Foley's behavior. As far as I'm concerned, Mahoney is a piece of shit and should resign. He got caught so he should go. Period. Bottom line. Done. Over.

Unless, of course, you'd like me to drive to his home, smack him upside his empty head and yell at him. Would that suffice, pencil dick?

Is there anything else you'd like to distract me with? Something new to distract from the fact that McFailin and Painful are down double digits in the polls?

"She's Cheney in drag." Me

The last "debate..."

Is, I think, finally going to pull the "Flush" lever on Crash's campaign. If he does go on the attack, sitting at a table and having to look at Obama when he spouts his bullshit, that's not going to sit well with the undecideds who just found out their jobs have gone to China and they'll have to get a divorce to keep their health insurance.

Tonight I'm making Blackened Chicken, because Obama is going to burn that plane-crashing coward to a crisp, and my healthier version of fettuccine Alfredo, because what's a debate without cheese?

Would McCain talk better if the moderator wore a Viet Cong uniform?

You don't have to burn books to destroy a culture. Just get people to stop reading them.
---Ray Bradbury

I cannot see how McFailin can make is through this debate

with some semblance of civility - considering his behavior the last two go-arounds, and, I'm sure he'll get his Depends in a massive wad once Obama bitch-slaps him over Ayers, et al, so we're bound to be visited upon by the Grumpy Old Bastard again.

Blackened Chicken with a 'healthy' alfredo ... and what kind of wine will you be enjoying?

I'm thinking blackened flank steak on the grill - that would be a symbolic meal, too!

"Would McCain talk better if the moderator wore a Viet Cong uniform?"

LOL - brootal, you candy-ass, unpatriotic, nazi gay-luvin, Amurkun hatin', librul ...

"She's Cheney in drag." Me

From the whine list...

What with Clucky McChicken's "economic plan," Two-Buck Chuck wold have been most appropriate, but I just can't take it! I'm opting for a nice Paso Robles Chardonnay...heavily oaked, because Clucky probably hasn't had any wood in decades!

And PLEASE, Pook. That's candy-ass, unpatriotic, nazi gay-luvin, Amurkun hatin', DEMO-MOOZLIM librul to you!

You don't have to burn books to destroy a culture. Just get people to stop reading them.
---Ray Bradbury

Paso Robles Chardonnay - mmmm - NICE!

I'm thinking of going with a nice red tonight ... since I'm partial to Fat Bastard wines, perhaps a nice merlot will do my blackened steak justice!

Oh, my! My BAD!! Will you ever forgive me, you candy-ass, unpatriotic, nazi gay-luvin, Amurkun hatin' DEMO-MOOZLIM librul??

"She's Cheney in drag." Me

Fat Bastard's actually pretty good...

I find I need to open their reds about an hour before I want to drink it. French wine tends to have a more earthy, almost mineral finish.

Oh wait! I guess I'm a candy-ass, unpatriotic, nazi gay-luvin, Amurkun hatin' demo-moozlim, WINE SIPPING ELITIST librul!

You don't have to burn books to destroy a culture. Just get people to stop reading them.
---Ray Bradbury

Yeah, tonight ought to be a

Yeah, tonight ought to be a hoot just watching the look on Hussein's face when McCain asks him to explain truthfully his relationship with a terrorist. Hussein will start stuttering in his usual way and his eyes will become as big as his ears as he glances around looking for a teleprompter and there won't be one. About this time, the liberal moderator will cry foul and that discussion will end as the liberal media again protects his dumbass from having to answer anything of significance.

And I see, liberalbluepussy, that your wife will again have you in the kitchen like the bitch you are, fixing her dinner. Just damn! It amazes me so much how pussified you liberal male momma's boys are.

Ya know, cracker ...

Perhaps if you got your head out from your daughter/wife/sister/mother's festering and rank pussy once in a while, you'd already know the answer to McFailin's silly question about Ayers. Obama has only said it at least a dozen times, but, you go ahead and play fucking ignorant like that coward McFailin- it suits both of your punk-asses.

Can't wait to see McFailin' lie to Obama's face and how nice it will be when Obama shows class, calm and coolness under McFailin's silly questions. Obama will once again prove to be the presidential candidate on the stage, while McFailin' reminds everyone of what a hypocritical, uneducated and lying sack of shit he is.

But, hey, if pretending McFailin's anything but a piece of shit is what gets you through your miserable day, have at it, honky!

On another note, I see McFailin's buddying up to a supporter of a terrorist ... spin this, mother fucker:

"Fun Fact: Saddam's Lobbyist? Also McCain's Transition Chief"
http://www.kxmc.com/News/Nation/285674.asp

"McCain Adviser Linked To Saddam "
http://news.sky.com/

"McCain Transition Chief Aided Saddam In Lobbying Effort"
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/10/14/mccain-transition-chief-a_n_134...

"She's Cheney in drag." Me

And you think you're some kind of big man?

What a punk-ass little coward and bully you are. If you were any kind of man at all, you'd face me and say those things. But what am I saying? Hatey wouldn't and neither will you.

Fuck you, clay eating white trash. You're going to cry for your little whore mammy when Obama is inaugurated.

And fuck your family. Oh wait. Every big black stud in town has already done that.

You don't have to burn books to destroy a culture. Just get people to stop reading them.
---Ray Bradbury

ROFLMFAO....I just love it

ROFLMFAO....I just love it when you try to act like a real man. What is your fascination with big black studs?

The fact that the idea pisses you off, whoreson...

I have accused your entire family of adultery in response to your "fighting words." And still you bully and whine and refuse to man the fuck up. I am both amazed and ready to puke at the thought of you. What piss poor excuse for a man must you be? Sling what you southern types call fighting words then run behind that computer. Your family thinks you suck.

You're actually proud of being a coward, aren't you? It should be no surprise though. You support a coward who accuses his opponent of treason through others. A phony officer who crashed expensive aircraft and sang to the Viet Cong like a yellow little birdie. With a "maverick" like that for a role model, no wonder you're a failed man.

If I really believed god existed, I'd pray that someone kicks your ass one day, since I guess I don't get to do it. White trash scumbucket. November 5, cry me a fuckin' river when you're calling a black man "Mister President!"

You don't have to burn books to destroy a culture. Just get people to stop reading them.
---Ray Bradbury

Bebe,

When your canidate has nothing to offer but hate and lies it means that he is in the tank, and is grasping at straws. You and people like you are totally useless, and you and farmer, and other sock puppets want to burn a cross in my front yard. Just bring one other thing some hot dogs, and remember one thing though I am a gun owner and I am not afraid to use it.

FREE LEONARD PELTIER
www.aimovement.org
www.layoffinhofe.com
www.autismrocks.org
www.andrewriceforoklahoma.com

LOLOL....you boys are sooo

LOLOL....you boys are sooo funny. Don't you know? Cross burning went out years ago. No self respecting patriot burns crosses in anyone's yard any longer. Waste of wood.

And you are an unrepentant

evil, godless baby killer.

What is wrong with you?

What is wrong with you?

Nothing wrong with me.

What is wrong with you? You support killing babies and pregnant women in a war based on lies. You support this illegal war that kills babies so you are a baby killer. There was no reason to invade Iraq, yet you support it. This means that you support the unnecessary murder of babies. But those are just BROWN babies, so who cares, right? Fucking hypocrite baby murderer.

Wow, you are such a nut. If

Wow, you are such a nut. If it's an illegal war, why hasn't the Dem lead congress shut it down. They've had 2 years to yank the funding they approved.

It is an illegal war and we dont have the votes.

But we will after Nov 5. We decent moral Americans will stop the carnage that you demon worshipping scum have let loose on the innocent Iraqi people. Your baby murdering days are almost over.

You see, JJFlash, gutter

You see, JJFlash, gutter trask...aka.....pukie doesn't say anything about Mahoney because she wishes he, or any man for that matter, would actually make a pass at her despicable self since her babbydaddy left her years ago.

LMAO - that's the best you can do, white trash??!!

Weak IMAGINATION, honky, VERY weak!!

"She's Cheney in drag." Me

Idiot moron.

Wright spent six years in the US Marines and received an "honorable discharge".

Wright grew up in a country that had "white only" restrooms, lunch counters and drinking fountains. Sammy Davis Jr. and Josephine Baker could perform in nightclubs but could only enter through the back door of that very same nightclub. Blacks rode the back of the bus. They were the victims of experiments.

Josephine Baker became the first American-born woman to receive the highest French military honor, the Croix de Guerre for putting her life in jeopardy as she spied for the Allies during WWII, she was born and raised in America, and yet, was not allowed to enter a nightclub where she entertained unless it was through the "servants entrance".

Still, in spite of everything he went through, Wright served honorably in the US Marines for six years and received an honorable discharge. If you haven't put at least as much into this country as Wright has, then shut the fuck up.

Hypocracy is a human condition

that people of faith, religious and otherwise, try to overcome, with varying degrees success. Those on this site, who claim to be working for a better world, but express hate, or denigrate those they disagree with, are an example of hypocracy. How can one make this world a better place by hating those you disagree with?

"How can one make this world a better

place by hating those you disagree with?"

Because you're an asshole and one less asshole in this world will go far. Therefore, do your part asshole, and drop dead.

"She's Cheney in drag." Me

That's why I could never support

the neo-com agenda, no matter its merits. The people who support the neo-com agenda seem to also support hate speech and racism.

*yawn*

If that's the way you're going to talk at Barnes & Noble today, it's going to be a really short conversation. I'll need a nap after that, I think.

You don't have to burn books to destroy a culture. Just get people to stop reading them.
---Ray Bradbury

Blah, blah, blah. You are a BORE, porch monkey.

"She's Cheney in drag." Me

He is a coward as well

I proposed we converse in the café at Barnes and Noble, since "he is in Oceanside this week." Of course, the dipshit didn't show nor did the "civil authorities" that he bragged he would bring along for my arrest. Now he's trying to say the meeting was at Pendleton. I never agreed to that; I said a NEUTRAL location. Clearly our Momotose is doing what he does best: farting out his false-bravado bean breeze.

There's still Thursday at B & N, Hatey. I might have to go to L.A. so we'll make it 4 pm in the café.

You don't have to burn books to destroy a culture. Just get people to stop reading them.
---Ray Bradbury

I dont want you and your kind to support our agenda

You are a fascist and a domestic terrorist. You should be arrested, your citizenship revoked and be sent out of our country. There is no place in America for lying, anti American traitors like you.

The world would be a better place

if you stupid right wingers would have paid a little attention in school and learned to spell. It is HYPOCRISY not HYPOCRACY. How can the world ever be a better place if we have uneducated morons like you running around? We taxpayers have to support you dummies.

Hufflarry

Tell that to the guest blogger. He spells it just as I do.

You spell it that way

because you are an uneducated dumbass. Many of your lying posts are pure gibberish.

Missing the Point

Let's see: you didn't see the film but you comment on it anyway, and like many people who wish to change the subject, you criticize what's NOT in the film as if Maher or any one else has an obligation to make the kind of film you'd make. Make your own film then and stop whining.

The point of Religulous is NOT about nationalism, it's about the silly sets of assumptions and unsupportable beliefs behind ALL religions. In a word, "faith". Not logic, not analysis, not evidence - faith. What is most admirable about MLK, Ghandi, Einstein is their commitment to social justice and human brotherhood. (Anti-fervent-nationalism is at best a subset of that). For 2 of them, part of that impetus may have been religion, but that hardly elevates my opinion of them. I'd like them both better if they hadn't had that motivation. If they needed that crutch then fine - but that's no reason to praise the need for crutches.

Besides, it's a stretch to imply that Ghandi's remark was an endorsement of all religions. It was a remark about our common humanity REGARDLESS of individual religions, or for that matter, our different cultures. And Einstein's references to God were about as generic as many of the Deist assumptions of Founding Fathers that there was a God - detached from any specific branch of Christianity.

Sure, Jesse Jackson believes in a Christian God as did Adolph Hitler. That fact makes Christianity not one bit more credible or incredible - Christianity is still a childish set of myths and superstitions no matter WHO supports it and in which way they interpret it. Likewise the other religions and cults.

I'm ambivalent about Maher himself but his mind is no more "mediocre" than your argument that National security is the true issue here. We're talking about organized religion here and if calling con-men con-men is a "sin" then I'll take my chances at punishment from a non-existent Deity. Besides, isn't one of the 10 commandments about bearing false witness? What else can you call a human that claims absolute knowledge without evidence, facts, analysis, etc. Oh yeah - not a liar - someone with "faith".

Exactly! Perfect response.

Exactly!

Perfect response. I agree completely.

Sorry to post on topic:

There are other ethical foundations.

One says evil really is petty, mean, and depraved because it is the portion of a truly finite existence that is absolutely wasted.

"Only those who accept completely their limited human existence can be truly mystical." - Ludwig Wittgenstein

FOR ALL OF YOU THAT WANT TO

FOR ALL OF YOU THAT WANT TO KNOW WHO THE REAL BARACK HUSSEIN OBAMA IS CHECK THIS OUT. THE REAL BARACK OBAMA.

http://www.americanthinker.com/2008/10/this_could_be_the_game_changer.ht...

LOL

'americanthinker"? Why don't you post something from clownhall.com, too, and call it a day, trailer park trash ...

"She's Cheney in drag." Me

Fuck you again, whore's son!

Did you ever figure out WHY your kids look just like "LaDeon" who tends bar down at the Sidetrack Tap?

You don't have to burn books to destroy a culture. Just get people to stop reading them.
---Ray Bradbury

Liked that didn't you,

Liked that didn't you, gutter trash. The real Hussein. And you thought you really knew your savior, huh.

I wouldn't know, trailer park. I didn't click on your link.

And I have no desire to, either, therefore, your stupid remark is ... worthless.

"She's Cheney in drag." Me

Holy Shit!

I just found out why bebe's such a pissed-off little white trash boy!

Many Pastors Dismiss Mental Illness In Their Flocks

Aww, pooor little Aunt Bee. I bet Brother Jim-bob-ray done told him that thar dee-pressification he feels, is just because he's Out Of God's Will by letting his "wife" and daughters whore around for his beer money.

Pray for deliverance from your Spirit of Cowardice, bebe! Meantime, as your candy-ass candidate sinks slowly in the West, I'll play you a tune...

I hope you go REALLY postal on Election Night and actually mouth off to a live person. I'd love to be the one to kick your Redbone ass personally, but I guess someone else will have to enjoy that.

You don't have to burn books to destroy a culture. Just get people to stop reading them.
---Ray Bradbury

LMAO - No wonder Pappy's such a mess!

His pastor misdiagnosed his bipolar tendancies!! Wonder if Dog will help him with that ...

"She's Cheney in drag." Me

LOLOL.....yeah, I got your

LOLOL.....yeah, I got your pussy self riled up, huh bitch. You keep that anger up so you can whip up your manly wife a real dinner, little man. You did, however, make my day with your little "I'd love to be the one to kick your Redbone ass personally" comment. Gave me a visual of your little self walking up to me crying ans begging not to kick your punk ass in front of the wife. That made me grin. So thanks. Now go away or I shall be forced to make sport of you some more.

We get it, Clay Eater

You're a coward and a piss poor excuse for a man. Is everyone in the South a bragging coward like you? No wonder we kicked your asses at Gettysburg. I hear the grapeshot tore Rebels' guts out as they ran like little faggots.

I am getting sick of you people and your cowardly idle threats. Any time, Redbone. Name it. You're such a big ole mother trucker, you must get to California at times, even if it's only to get a new dose of STD from some underage lot lizard. God, I hope you don't stick that nasty thing in your daughter when you're through.

You don't have to burn books to destroy a culture. Just get people to stop reading them.
---Ray Bradbury

Comments

(61)
<